Policymakers Need Broader Historical Comparisons, Not Familiar Analogies
In *History’s Dead-Hand Grip*, editors Joseph Ledford and Daniel J. Sargent argue that policymakers cannot avoid using history, but can mistake familiar analogies and inherited narratives for reliable guides to action. Drawing on international case studies, they make the case for comparing a wider range of evidence before drawing lessons from the past. Historical analysis, they contend, can clarify what policy choices are feasible and widen the options decision-makers see, but it cannot determine the purposes those choices should serve.
Hoover Institution·Nov 18, 2026·21 min read