Leaders Get Better Results by Investigating Why People Resist Change
Leadership expert Philip Jameson argues that people proposing workplace changes often mistake the benefits they see for reasons others will adopt them. In his TED talk, he urges leaders to ask why people will not make the change, then investigate the missing skills, practical frictions or perceived losses behind that reluctance. The answer, he says, should determine how leaders respond.

A good idea can still meet practical resistance
Philip Jameson starts with a business leader who kept pitching ways for his team to work together better and faster. The ideas rarely took hold. “I don’t understand why they won’t just change,” the leader told him.
That question, Jameson argues, starts in the wrong place. People proposing change often see its benefits as obvious: the new way is smarter, faster or fairer. When colleagues do not adopt it, the proposer can struggle to understand why. But people expected to change may face barriers the proposer has not considered.
Jameson describes two approaches. Dreamers ask, “Why wouldn’t people do it?” They focus on the case for the change and assume others will see its value. Detectives ask, “Why won’t people do it?” They investigate the frictions and disincentives that could keep people from changing, even when the proposal seems sound. Jameson says it is consistently the detectives who get better results.
Why won't people do it?
The distinction is between treating the benefits as self-evident and investigating what might prevent people from acting. A detective looks beyond the advocate’s belief that the new way is better and asks what the people affected by it are facing.
The obstacle determines the response
A hotel chain wanted staff to use a newer tool for setting room prices, one that relied more on automation and machine learning. Through investigation, the chain’s leaders learned that staff members were skeptical: they were not convinced the tool could improve on their own pricing instincts. The leaders brought the chain’s most skilled and experienced staff into an early user group to signal to the organization that the tool was valuable. Before long, the vast majority of staff with access to it were using it every week.
The example shows why it matters to find out what is holding people back before deciding how to respond. Jameson offers three questions for that investigation.
The first is: what knowledge and skills are people missing? There may be gaps in what people know about the change, or in their ability to play their part. If that is the barrier, the response is to give them the information and tools they need.
The second is: what frictions will get in people’s way? People may feel they lack the time or resources to do things differently. Other people may also be quietly encouraging them not to change. Jameson’s suggested responses are practical and direct: provide time and resources, and have hard conversations with influential people who are discouraging the change.
The third is: why won’t people want to change? People may see no benefit for themselves, or feel they have something to lose. The loss may involve status or the nature of the work. Jameson gives the example of a person asked to run a new risk assessment who designed the old one; the change may represent a loss of status. An operations manager who loves scheduling truck deliveries may see an automated system as taking away a treasured, creative activity.
For these concerns, information or resources may not be enough. Jameson says leaders may need to help people see things differently, alleviate fears they consider unfounded, or show how they will personally help prevent the worst outcomes. The questions help distinguish between a lack of knowledge or skill, practical and social frictions, and a perceived loss. Each points toward a different response.
Ask directly, and do not turn reluctance into a character judgment
Imagining why someone might resist is useful, but Jameson recommends asking them directly—in a meeting or over coffee. “Ask out loud,” he says. Rather than rely only on a guess about the barrier, speak with the person expected to change.
One conversation may not uncover everything. Jameson notes that complex barriers, such as deep personal fears, may not become apparent until simpler ones, such as not having enough time, have been addressed. His advice is to ask more than once.
He also warns against moralizing. When people do not behave as expected, it can be tempting to call them lazy or resistant. But Jameson says that judgment does not help produce successful, sustained change. Investigating what is getting in the way gives the person proposing change something to act on.
The same questions can apply outside work, Jameson says. Someone may want a sister to use the family shared calendar or an old friend to send more life updates. In either case, the useful question is not why the person should see the change as worthwhile, but why they will not make it. The answer may reveal a barrier that a pitch for the change would miss.


