Orply.

A 3-2-5 Growth Model Shows How Clean Energy Can Squeeze Out Fossil Fuels

Michael LiebreichTEDThursday, November 19, 20265 min read

Energy analyst Michael Liebreich argues that the clean-energy transition is underway, even though fossil-fuel use has not yet begun to fall sharply. In a four-line model of the global energy system, he shows how clean-energy supply growing faster than demand for useful energy can gradually squeeze fossil fuels out, without bans. The model is an illustration, not a forecast: its central claim is that the transition depends on sustaining clean-energy growth and electrification long enough for the gap to close.

The transition is a contest between growth rates

Michael Liebreich argues that the clean-energy transition is underway, but not in the form often implied by steep emissions pathways consistent with limiting warming to 1.5°C. Those pathways show emissions falling sharply; Liebreich says the transition’s early stages will not look like a dramatic reduction in fossil-fuel use. His explanation starts with a simple model of the energy system: clean supply can grow faster than demand for useful energy, gradually shrinking the space left for fossil fuels.

The model has four lines. The economy grows at 3 percent a year. Demand for useful energy grows more slowly, at 2 percent, because of efficiency. Clean-energy supply grows at 5 percent. Fossil fuels fill the gap between demand and clean supply. Liebreich says clean supply has been growing at more than 5 percent annually, but holds its future growth at 5 percent to keep the illustration simple.

3% / 2% / 5%
Annual growth assumptions: economy, useful-energy demand, clean-energy supply

In the model, fossil-fuel demand does not immediately collapse. It can keep growing for the first couple of decades. Over time, though, clean supply grows faster than useful-energy demand, narrowing the remaining gap and eventually pushing fossil fuels off the system.

Liebreich stresses that this is an illustration, not a complete forecast. Difficult sectors will leave a long tail, some carbon removal may be needed, and the model covers the energy system—not land use or agricultural emissions. Its point is about the shape of a transition: a new technology can expand for years before the old one begins to decline.

He compares that pattern with cars replacing horses and mobile phones replacing landlines. Neither transition required banning the older technology, he says; in both cases, the old technology continued growing for around 30 years after the new one arrived before collapsing. The practical question, then, is how to keep clean-energy supply growing faster than demand.

Useful energy shows a transition that primary-energy shares can hide

Electricity provides one visible sign of that growth. Wind and solar, which together generated less than 1 percent of global electricity two decades ago, now provide about 20 percent, Liebreich says, despite electricity demand having doubled over the same period. He says solar generation has doubled every three years and wind every five. Together, they are about to overtake gas in the global electricity mix; add hydropower, and the combined sources have already overtaken coal.

Solar alone, and wind alone, each generate more electricity than all the world’s nuclear plants, Liebreich says. With a background in nuclear engineering, he supports building new nuclear plants and says large plants have stopped being shut down. But he argues that expectations should reflect the scale of the competition: small modular reactors would need to be built by the thousands, not dozens or hundreds, to catch up with the growth represented by wind and solar.

The familiar objection that the sun does not shine at night leads, in Liebreich’s account, to batteries rather than a halt in renewable growth. He points to a 2019 Bloomberg New Energy Finance forecast that projected battery-sales growth of 25 percent a year. He says the realized growth rate was 45 percent, doubling every two years.

A different measure can make progress look less substantial. Liebreich cites a 2025 Foreign Affairs article by Dan Yergin, Peter Orszag and Atul Arya, which said hydrocarbons’ share of global primary energy had changed little, from 85 percent in 1990 to about 80 percent “today.” He argues that this comparison spans Asia’s coal-fired growth and six oil-price crises that damaged the economy.

More fundamentally, primary energy measures what goes into the energy system, not what reaches people as useful heat, mobility, lighting or cooling. Liebreich says more than two-thirds of primary energy is lost in conversions from fuel to heat and then to electricity or motion. These losses follow from thermodynamics, he argues; they are not simply evidence of inefficient machines.

On the measure of useful energy, Liebreich cites International Energy Agency figures showing that electricity supplies 37 percent and clean energy already supplies about 30 percent. For him, that is the relevant starting point for asking how quickly clean energy can provide the services the economy needs.

Electrification can keep clean supply growing

Liebreich says the model’s assumptions depend on continuing to expand clean-energy supply and electrify more of the economy. He identifies AI as a potential tool for accelerating energy innovation, and points to transport and heating as areas where electrification is already advancing.

Globally, one in three new cars sold is electric, he says; in China, it is two in three. Sales of fossil-fueled cars peaked in 2017 and are already a third lower. One in three heavy trucks sold in China is electric, compared with one in 25 in Europe. Liebreich also points to a heavy-vehicle charging hub in Valencia, Spain, built by PragmaCharge, a company he chairs.

Heating is another opportunity in his account. He says half of heating systems are already electric, and argues that electric systems are cheaper, better and healthier, while also providing air-conditioning. Half of industrial heat is low-temperature heat, which he says is well suited to heat pumps; even high-temperature industrial heat, he adds, can be delivered electrically.

Hydrogen, in Liebreich’s view, is not the next clean-energy “miracle.” The later stages of the transition will require further hard-tech innovation. He is confident that a completely clean economy will eventually arrive because burning fuels is, as he puts it, bad thermodynamics and bad economics, harmful to people and the planet, and damaging to security. Pragmatism need not mean accepting defeat, he concludes; it can mean leaning in and speeding up.

The frontier, in your inbox tomorrow at 08:00.

Sign up free. Pick the industry Briefs you want. Tomorrow morning, they land. No credit card.

Sign up free