Warmth Makes Competence Easier to Trust
Vanessa Van Edwards argues that charisma is learned—and that warmth is what allows competence to earn trust. In her coaching conversation with Sam Parr, she says people who rely on expertise alone can come across as suspicious or hard to approach, while deliberate signals of warmth make their ideas easier to hear. Her advice is not to imitate a fixed model of likability, but to develop a communication style that feels like your own.

Warmth is what lets competence land
Vanessa Edwards argues that charisma is learned. The most charismatic people she knows have developed their own way of communicating. Their style may eventually look natural, but over time you can see what they have honed: humor, gestures, or a particular approach to ideas. She says it is difficult to tell at first whether someone’s charisma is learned or innate; in conversation, though, a person’s distinct “flavor” may reveal the work behind it. Fake charisma, she adds, is easier to detect than practiced skill.
Her practical starting point is a two-part model of first impressions: warmth and competence. Edwards says these account for 82% of our impressions of people. Her matrix distinguishes four combinations: high competence and warmth produces trust; high competence without warmth produces suspicion; low competence and warmth produces pity; and low levels of both produce contempt. Her point is not that competence is unimportant. It is that competence presented without warmth may be received skeptically.
| Competence | Warmth | Impression |
|---|---|---|
| High | High | Trust |
| High | Low | Suspicion |
| Low | High | Pity |
| Low | Low | Contempt |
Competence without warmth is likely to leave us feeling suspicious.
Smart people, Edwards argues, often overemphasize showing what they know. They may enter a room with the data, numbers, or expertise ready, only to find that people doubt the figures or hesitate to trust the person presenting them. She says this can make negotiations and closing harder. In her account, warmth helps make competence believable: it is “like a lubricant” that makes intelligence easier to take in.
Warmth does not mean being a bubbly extrovert. Edwards says it can show up as humor, sarcasm, vulnerability, or even stumbling over your words. When Sam Parr raises Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg as examples of successful people who may not seem conventionally likable, Edwards argues that each has a different kind of warmth. She points to Musk’s lack of polish and willingness to seem imperfect as a form of vulnerability. She describes Zuckerberg’s less expressive manner as another kind of warmth: the impression of an everyday person who happened to have a good idea. Smiling constantly or adding conspicuous hand gestures is not the point.
That distinction matters because “just be yourself” is not useful advice to someone who wants to change. Parr says he disliked the phrase when he was younger and trying to meet women: if he did not like the way he came across, why should he preserve it? Edwards says she had a similar reaction. She also rejects “smile more.” In her view, a fake smile can make someone seem manipulative or strange; she offers Elizabeth Holmes as an example of advice to appear more likable backfiring. The aim is not to perform a generic version of warmth, but to develop a way of showing it that feels like your own.
Edwards describes likability as a lubricant for ideas, not a tactic for getting people to do what you want. It can make someone’s intelligence easier to take in and make them easier to work with, invest in, buy from, or spend time with. Warmth and competence are not competing priorities: warmth is one way to help the other person hear the competence.
Connection opens the door; attention gives people a reason to stay
Edwards focuses on oxytocin and dopamine as two chemicals relevant to likability and conversation, while noting that each has many functions in the body. She describes oxytocin as a bonding chemical associated with the feeling that you want to know someone better or tell them something. Eye contact, touch, and shared moments of meaning can all contribute to connection, she says.
The first seconds of an encounter matter in this framework. Edwards says a person’s first minute can matter more than the next 30 minutes, and describes that early impression as almost irreversible. She connects this to a fast assessment of whether a stranger is friend or foe, and to the social signals people exchange. Her practical advice is to make eye contact rather than check email while entering a meeting, and to keep your hands visible. On video calls, she begins with an open palm and a greeting; in person, visible hands can lead into a handshake or other touch, if both people are comfortable. She says those early signals help establish connection.
Edwards also says a handshake may produce a particularly strong bonding response, comparing one handshake to roughly three hours’ worth of the eye-contact-related response. She acknowledges that the estimate is difficult to measure precisely.
The second chemical in her framework is dopamine, which Edwards describes not only as a source of pleasure but as a driver of motivation. A good conversation, she argues, should leave someone feeling that the time was worthwhile and that they have energy to respond, return a call, or continue working with you. In a world where people are constantly checking a feed, she says, conversation has to give them a reason to pay attention.
Novelty and an “information gap” can do that. Parr’s opening magic trick—introduced as something his daughter taught him—worked, Edwards says, because it offered something unfamiliar and made her curious about what would happen. The introduction created a question in her mind before the trick began.
Edwards names Howard Stern as a skilled creator of these gaps. Questions such as “Want to hear the weirdest thing that ever happened to me?” or “You want to know the worst piece of advice I’ve ever gotten?” promise an answer without giving it away. For speakers, she recommends using information hooks every minute or two before telling a story. The hook can be short; its job is to make the listener want the next sentence.
That technique works in ordinary conversation too. Instead of giving a routine answer to “How’s it going?”, Edwards suggests mentioning a recent goal reached, a strange event, or something you learned. A specific answer breaks the script and gives the other person something to respond to. In her account, connection makes an exchange easier to enter, while novelty gives it momentum.
The best conversational move may be to stop trying to impress
Parr describes two common conversational traps: planning what to say next and trying to impress the other person. Edwards’s answer is not to become strategically aloof. She rejects “treat them mean to keep them keen” and argues that, in ordinary conversation, making yourself impressive can make you less approachable.
She recalls attending a party where guests introduced themselves with grand achievements: one person said he had invented the internet and was a billionaire; another said he had cured cancer. When it was her turn, she introduced herself as a recovering awkward person who helped smart, awkward people communicate. The room laughed, and people came up to talk to her afterward. Edwards’s point is that the impressive introductions left her admiring their speakers but unsure what she would say to them. She would rather be easier to talk to than more impressive.
There are exceptions, she says: being impressive may help in traditional media, on a book tour, or when delivering a paid keynote. But in everyday conversation, it can put the other person on the back foot, making them feel less confident or more doubtful about what they have to say. The goal is not to hide what you know. It is to avoid making every interaction a test of who can display the most status.
That also complicates the familiar advice to ask lots of questions. Edwards says she is a social over-thinker and can ask so many follow-ups that she feels she is not getting anywhere. She distinguishes between “entertainers,” who enjoy being the center of attention and telling stories, and “appreciators,” who spend much of their day talking and may prefer to hear someone else’s stories, tips, or advice. Treating every important person as an entertainer—asking question after question—can backfire, she says, especially with investors or in boardrooms.
Parr tells her about a dinner with a person who had helped invent AI. The guest asked Parr how he used it and listened closely as Parr described a modest example: using it to work out what size shirts to buy online. Parr did not realize who he was talking to until about an hour into dinner. Edwards suggests the guest may have enjoyed the exchange precisely because he was tired of being asked questions and wanted to hear what Parr had to say. The conversational lane should fit the person.
Instead of rehearsing the next question, Edwards suggests following whichever topic lights up the conversation—either the other person’s interest or your own. She describes a study in which researchers collected sweat from people who had exercised and people who had skydived for the first time, then had participants smell the samples while their brains were scanned. Edwards says participants who smelled the fear-related sweat showed activity in the amygdala. She uses the study to explain how another person’s fear or nervousness can affect us.
Her practical recommendation is to find something you genuinely care about rather than trying to manufacture enthusiasm for the other person. A recent win, a strange event, or something you learned can change your face, voice, and choice of words, she says, and give both people more to work with. Parr deliberately uses one of her suggested hooks when he asks whether he can tell her about an offbeat leadership lesson. Edwards responds eagerly; afterward, Parr reveals that he did it on purpose. He offers a clear reason to listen, then tells a story that matters to him.
Make your signals purposeful, not louder
Parr connects Edwards’s account of emotional contagion to his experience training a badly behaved 80-pound pitbull. He says he learned from dog-training books and a trainer that a dog responds to its owner’s body language. If the owner becomes fearful when another dog approaches, the dog may pick up on that; a loud, high-energy correction can further excite it. Parr says he found a calmer, firmer response more useful. Edwards extends the analogy to workplaces: small interactions in an office or boardroom can shape whether people want to spend time or do business with you.
She calls the useful quality “purposeful” rather than simply positive. A leader trying to get a team through a sprint may need to bring productive, driving energy; a collaborative session calls for something different. Parr’s term is “chalant”: deliberately showing enthusiasm rather than trying to seem nonchalant. Edwards connects that idea to what she calls signal amplification bias: people may assume their signals are obvious when others do not pick them up.
To illustrate availability, Edwards cites a study by Monica Moore on courtship behavior. She says the women most often approached were those who sent the most availability signals. Edwards interprets the finding as evidence that availability can make a person more attractive because others feel safer approaching and expect their advances to be heard. She extends that idea to work: making it clear that you are open to conversation may help colleagues, partners, or potential friends approach you.
Appearance matters too, Edwards says, including attractiveness and height, though she describes these as advantages rather than requirements for charisma. Clothing and other visible cues, she argues, should be chosen with a purpose. A dating profile showing someone in ski gear may attract people who associate skiing with fun and travel, while turning off those who associate it with cold or danger. The objective is not to appeal to everyone; it is to signal clearly enough to attract people who are a good fit.
For professional conversations, she recommends listening for “trigger words”: subjects that reliably lead to an interesting path for you, or that reveal what excites the other person. She keeps a mental list of 20 to 50 such words. She also recommends playful guessing games as a way to make routine questions more engaging. If someone says they have children, try guessing their names; if they are going on vacation, guess where. The guesses can be wrong. The point is to introduce play and give the other person a chance to join in.
Edwards says playful wordplay can make a person more engaging while also raising their own energy. That can help people who dislike the idea that enthusiasm requires being louder or more demonstrative. Parr says he often teases people by pretending to recognize their hometown or school, then revealing that he is from Missouri.
Vocal confidence affects whether people listen or scrutinize
Edwards calls voice a signal of “contagious competence.” A speaker who sounds nervous can make listeners uncomfortable, she says. In her demonstration, she tightens her vocal cords, raises her pitch, and adds upward inflection at the ends of sentences. Parr says the effect is irritating. Edwards explains that the listener may register the nervousness rather than simply hearing the words.
She singles out question-like upward inflection—“up-talk”—as a common problem at the start of meetings and presentations. An opening such as “Good morning?” or “Happy to have everyone?” can make a statement sound like a question. Edwards says women may use up-talk more often because they are taught to appease, but that she also hears male students do it in the first ten seconds of calls and presentations. In her account, men may use it while trying to sound warmer.
Edwards says listeners can associate this inflection with uncertainty or deception. She describes research in which listeners’ brains shifted from listening to scrutinizing when they heard question-like inflection. She gives the example of stating a price as “the cost is $10,000?” rather than saying it plainly. In her view, asking the number can undermine confidence in a negotiation.
Her advice is concrete: review recordings of presentations or Zoom calls and listen to the opening seconds. Are you stating your point or asking it? Then review the most nerve-racking parts, such as the slide where you state your numbers, and practice those sections deliberately. Edwards says the first 30 seconds and the slides that make a speaker most nervous deserve particular attention.
She also recommends speaking from the most relaxed part of your vocal range, which she calls the maximum resonance point. It is toward the lower end, but not at the absolute lowest. When nervous, people may tighten their vocal cords and speak high in their range. Edwards coaches Parr to inhale and then speak on the exhale, demonstrating the difference between a tense, high “hello” and a more relaxed one. She warns against overcorrecting by forcing the voice too low. Edwards says she suspects Elizabeth Holmes may have read research favoring lower voices and pushed her own voice too far down; she qualifies that suggestion with “I think” and “I don’t know.” The practical instruction is to find a relaxed, resonant pitch rather than imitate someone else’s.
Language matters alongside delivery. Edwards suggests auditing your sent emails to see what words you use and how those words may shape other people’s behavior. She recounts a study in which participants played the same prisoner’s-dilemma-style game, but one group was told it was the “Wall Street game” and another the “community game.” Edwards says the reported cooperation rates differed substantially.
Edwards presents the contrast as evidence that a single word can cue different behavior. For leaders, that makes word choice a tool for setting the work’s direction. If the goal is speed and execution, she suggests using achievement-oriented language such as “win,” “succeed,” and “advance.” If the task requires openness or creative thinking, language about collaboration, brainstorming, and lateral thinking better signals the desired behavior. Leaders, she says, should be deliberate about which mode the team needs rather than relying on a generic motivational tone.
Parr worries that this makes the leader responsible for supplying the energy in every room. Edwards’s answer is that the alternative can be more draining: failing to communicate what you want, sitting through lifeless small talk, or leaving a meeting feeling disliked or disconnected. Purposeful cues take effort, she says, but may be less exhausting than repeatedly failing to connect.
Small talk is a gateway to the conversations that matter
Edwards says people connect through three levels. The first is general traits: facts such as what you do, where you are from, or whether you have children. She calls this “verbally Googling” someone. It can feel like small talk, but she argues that it is a necessary step rather than a detour. People need some basic context before they can move into more personal conversation.
The problem is that familiar questions can be flat. Edwards dislikes “What do you do?” because it can sound like a question about someone’s worth. She prefers “Working on anything exciting these days?” If someone likes their work, they can talk about it; if they do not, they can steer toward something they care about. Questions about hobbies can do the same work without making occupation the center of the exchange.
Edwards warns against trying to skip straight to intimate questions. Asking a stranger about their biggest dreams or what keeps them up at night may be too abrupt. Her advice is to do the basic work, but do it better: ask about what someone is working on, what they enjoy, or what they are looking forward to. Those questions preserve the function of small talk while giving the other person more room to choose their answer.
Once the basic facts are in place, the conversation can move to level two: personal concerns, including goals, values, and worries. This is where people decide whether they want to work with, hire, invest in, date, or befriend someone. Edwards suggests moving toward goals by asking about a project someone has already mentioned: what do they hope to accomplish with the book, business, or other work? Time markers—birthdays, New Year’s, or the start of a quarter—can also make goal questions feel natural. Learning is another route. Edwards recalls that she and Parr had talked about the books they were reading when they first met, which gave them a way into what interested them.
The third level is someone’s self-narrative: the story they tell themselves about who they are. Edwards says this is useful in hiring because it can reveal how a person interprets setbacks and their own capacity to overcome them. She describes a narrative she likes in employees: the “ambitious hero,” someone who sees themselves as having faced difficulties and moved through them with hard work, grit, and resilience. She wants people whose account of themselves gives them a reason to keep going when work gets difficult.
For hiring, Edwards favors behavioral questions about recent events over familiar prompts such as “Tell me about a time you overcame something.” A candidate may have a practiced answer to the standard question. Asking about the most recent hurdle, she says, makes it harder to rely on a prepared story and gives the interviewer a chance to hear how the person describes a real, recent challenge. She also uses hypotheticals to see how someone thinks. For an events manager, she might ask what they would do if a flight delay pushed an event back three hours.
Two more questions can help uncover a person’s outlook. One is “Do you feel lucky?” Edwards agrees with Parr that someone who feels lucky may be more likely to see opportunity and feel some control over their circumstances. She says people who feel unlucky can see the world as happening to them, while people who feel lucky may notice more possibilities. Her recommendation is to ask the question and listen to how the person explains their answer.
The other question is which book, film, or television character most resembles them—not in appearance, but in personality, values, and life choices. Edwards says people often struggle to describe their own self-narrative directly, but may find it easier to answer through a character. She calls the question personal and says to use care. Most important, she advises not to argue with the answer. Whether or not you agree with someone’s chosen character, the response can show how they see themselves.
Borrow useful delivery cues without borrowing a persona
When Parr asks whom to study, Edwards cautions against imitating a single charismatic person. Oprah’s style, she says, differs from Steve Jobs’s, Brené Brown’s, and Parr’s; copying someone else can make you feel fake, and she argues that feeling fake can itself be contagious.
Her suggested exercise is to watch a range of popular TED talks and notice which speakers hold your attention. She names the talks as a way to sample very different delivery styles: Simon Sinek’s approach differs from Ken Robinson’s, which differs from Brené Brown’s. The point is not to borrow a persona but to identify the qualities that work for you. Does the speaker pace the stage? Use large gestures and facial expressions? Speak calmly and deliberately? Edwards says the answer can help you find a workable blend of warmth and competence.
For a high-status guest or colleague, she offers mirroring as a way to show respect and establish alignment. She says it should be used carefully; too much can feel strange. Mirroring can happen verbally, vocally, and physically. If someone speaks slowly, leaves long pauses, and uses a low volume, you can adjust your pace and volume toward theirs. If they are energetic and expressive, you can increase your own animation without going so far that you feel uncomfortable.
Verbally, the same idea means listening to the words someone uses and adopting their terminology when you understand it. If they talk about “clients” rather than “customers,” Edwards suggests using “clients,” not because the word itself is magic but because matching their vocabulary can make the exchange feel more aligned. She cautions against using terms you do not understand.
Edwards draws a boundary between charisma and manipulation: intention matters. Using these signals to harm, deceive, or trick someone is manipulative, she says. Using them to connect, work together, or help someone hear your ideas is different. Parr jokes that he still feels analyzed; Edwards answers that her intention is to connect. The techniques are not a substitute for good intent. They are ways to make attention, warmth, and respect more legible.
The business is built to spread the curriculum beyond its founder
Edwards says most of her revenue comes from speaking, including corporate training and consulting. Courses are another major part of the business: People School is a flagship program for high-achieving leaders, with office hours, workshops, homework, and assignments. She also earns royalties from books and a LinkedIn Learning course, teaches through MasterClass, teaches a full-credit course at Harvard in some semesters, and takes social-media sponsorships that fit.
She says she began posting on YouTube in 2007 and has published a video every week since. She wanted to write books and work from home while raising a family, but did not expect the business to grow to its current scale. The company has ten employees, and Edwards says its videos received 300 million views in the previous year.
A newer part of the model is certification. Companies can pay to train an internal communication coach—such as someone in HR or technology—rather than hiring Edwards herself, whom she says is too expensive. She sees that as a major direction for the next five years. Her longer-term ambition is to have a Chief Communication Officer, or Chief Conversation Officer, in every company, certified to use the curriculum.
Edwards wants the material used in schools, organizations, and companies, with other people delivering it rather than the business depending primarily on her own voice. She connects that ambition to communication’s growing importance as AI affects how people communicate. The business, in her telling, is not only books, training, and a founder’s speaking calendar; it is also an effort to establish an internal role for communication and equip more people to teach the curriculum.



