Cheating Begins With Cultivated Desire, Not Every Passing Thought
Alex O’Connor argues that fidelity depends not only on what a person does, but on whether they choose to cultivate desire for someone else. In a discussion with Chris Williamson, he says pornography may count as cheating depending on a couple’s boundaries, and that repeatedly indulging lust can reinforce objectification and make infidelity more likely. His practical advice is to limit situations and media that feed temptation, rather than treat exposure as training in self-control.

The moral distinction is between noticing desire and feeding it
Alex O’Connor argues that fantasising about someone else is not automatically equivalent to cheating. The distinction is between noticing attraction and choosing to entertain it. A person may see someone attractive while married; the mere thought, O’Connor says, is not the moral failure. What matters is whether they cultivate it—returning to it, elaborating it, and giving desire room to grow.
It’s not just thinking a thought. It’s not like a thought creeping into your mind; it seems to be entertaining that thought.
That is how he reads Jesus’s warning that looking at a woman with lust is adultery “in the heart.” He rejects the charge that this makes an involuntary thought a kind of “thought crime.” The target, in his account, is not a thought that simply appears, but the decision to engage with it.
Chris Williamson tests the boundary with an erotic dream involving a friend of the dreamer’s wife. The dreamer did not cheat, but could he claim credit for resisting? O’Connor answers that the question cuts both ways: if someone deserves praise for what they did in a dream, perhaps they can also be blamed for other dream actions. Dreams might express something about the subconscious, he allows, but their meaning is too uncertain to treat them as reliable evidence of character.
The dream also points to a difficulty in judging fidelity: desire and intention may matter more than the physical act, but they are harder to observe. O’Connor contrasts a partner who strongly wants to sleep with someone but is refused with one who does not want sex but is made to have it. In the second case, he says, the partner is a victim. Williamson names what distinguishes the first case: “The volition and desire.” O’Connor agrees, while noting that even people themselves may struggle to measure what is happening internally.
Pornography can matter even when a couple defines cheating differently
O’Connor says a physical act is a convenient marker of cheating, but not necessarily the morally decisive one. Couples can set different boundaries: people in a polyamorous relationship may permit sex with others, while another couple might agree that sleeping with one particular person is off limits. What counts as cheating depends partly on the commitments the partners have made. He says pornography, too, can be a form of cheating, depending on the relationship.
That flexibility does not make private desire irrelevant. O’Connor’s moral claim is that someone serious about a relationship should try to shut down fantasies that threaten it rather than indulge them. He argues that regular pornography use is associated with greater objectification of women and a greater likelihood of cheating. In his account, repeated indulgence does not build resistance; it may make a person more likely to see women as sexual objects.
He illustrates the problem of resistance with a story about Thomas Aquinas. As O’Connor recounts it, Aquinas’s family, worried about his devotion to theology, hired a prostitute to tempt him; Aquinas drove her from the castle with a burning stick. O’Connor says this is not advice to follow. His larger point is that discussions of pornography can focus on men’s self-control while overlooking the women affected by men’s behavior.
O’Connor says women in pornography can have harmful experiences, and that women outside it may also face risks from expectations shaped by pornography. He points to men trying to strangle women the first time they have sex, without first establishing that it is wanted or safe; he says this was not something people were doing 50 years ago. He links indulged lust more broadly to catcalling, uncomfortable staring, and behavior that comes to seem acceptable. The religious framing is that indulging lust is spiritually damaging; the secular one, he says, is that it can contribute to objectification, with women bearing much of the cost.
Reducing temptation is different from training through exposure
Williamson raises the case for exposure: if someone needs stronger self-control, should they not practise resisting temptation? He recalls advice attributed to Arthur Brooks that business owners should not hold retreats where employees can attend without their partners. In Williamson’s account, a new setting, proximity, and attraction among colleagues can combine to produce infidelity.
O’Connor says a committed person should be able to refuse even a highly tempting opportunity. If someone insists they could not say no to an attractive, naked person, he says, they need to work on their mental conditioning. Williamson presses the analogy with physical training: avoiding every challenge might leave a person fragile. O’Connor acknowledges the tension but questions whether exposure is a wise way to build resistance. He argues that pornography may reinforce objectification and make cheating more likely, rather than serve as practice in resisting desire.
His practical recommendation is to reduce the occasions that trigger temptation, not deliberately seek them out. Just as a couple might avoid a partner-free company retreat, a person might keep away from pornography or from social-media feeds that pull them toward lustful thoughts. O’Connor says his own Instagram feed is oriented toward biblical studies and music, though he still finds himself doom-scrolling. He describes trying to avoid being pulled into random content and notes that users can shape the topics their feeds serve them.
The responsibility may extend beyond a single act. O’Connor asks readers to consider discovering that a partner has spent ten years secretly pining after a co-worker. The feelings may not have been chosen, he says, but failing to confront them—or disclose them—may still matter. A partner might have chosen to stay if they knew; they might not have. Concealment keeps that choice from them.



